The Secret Menu at All Good Café You Need to Try

All Good Café may be known for its hearty brunches, soulful live music, and retro charm—but did you know they’ve got a secret menu? That’s right. Hidden gems not listed on the board, whispered by regulars, and passed down like folklore. From off-the-menu creations to special tweaks on classics, this is where the real magic happens. Ready to unlock the café’s best-kept secrets?

Secret Menu

Most cafes have a few tricks up their sleeves, but All Good Café takes it to a whole new level. Their secret menu isn’t some gimmick—it’s a beloved collection of insider favorites created by staff, loyal customers, and yes, even the chefs themselves.

Some items are nostalgic, some are over-the-top indulgent, and some are healthy twists you’d never expect. The key? You just have to ask.

Off Menu

Let’s break down a few must-try secret items floating around All Good Café:

1. The Elvis Biscuit
A buttery biscuit sandwich stuffed with peanut butter, banana, and crispy bacon. Inspired by the King himself, it’s sweet, salty, crunchy, and totally addictive.

2. Churro Pancakes
Think fluffy pancakes rolled in cinnamon sugar, topped with warm maple syrup and a dollop of whipped cream. Not listed anywhere—just ask your server for the “churro stack.”

3. Veggie Mash-Up
For plant-based eaters, ask for the “veggie mash-up.” It’s a combo of roasted seasonal vegetables, avocado, house-made hummus, and eggs (or tofu scramble), all served on sourdough. Clean, filling, and totally customizable.

4. Dirty Horchata Latte
This off-menu drink mixes house-made horchata with a shot of espresso. It’s creamy, slightly spicy, and has just the right caffeine kick.

5. The Backstage Burrito
A mega breakfast burrito filled with eggs, hash browns, bacon or tofu, sautéed veggies, and a drizzle of chipotle aioli. It’s what the musicians order after a late-night set—hence the name.

How to Order

You might be wondering how to actually order from the secret menu. Don’t worry—it’s easier than you think. Here are a few insider tips:

• Ask your server – They’re usually more than happy to let you in on a few favorites.
• Mention the name – If you know what it’s called (like “The Elvis Biscuit”), just say it.
• Be polite – Not all items may be available every day, depending on ingredients.
• Customize – Many secret menu items started from customer tweaks. Don’t be afraid to ask for changes.

Being in-the-know means being part of the All Good Café family. Regulars love sharing their discoveries, and staff love when people get creative.

Seasonal Surprises

One of the coolest parts of the secret menu? It changes with the seasons. Some items only appear during the fall or winter months, like:

• Pumpkin Pie Latte – made with real pumpkin purée and warm spices.
• Cranberry Brie Grilled Cheese – tart and creamy, perfect on a cold day.
• Spiced Apple Chai – a twist on chai with apple cider steamed in.

These specials aren’t always announced, so keep your ears open and ask the barista what’s new behind the scenes.

Why It Matters

Secret menus might sound silly to some, but they add something special to the café experience. It’s like being part of an inside joke—or finding a hidden level in your favorite game. You feel more connected to the place, the staff, and the culture.

All Good Café’s secret menu is a celebration of creativity and community. Whether it’s a mash-up meal made just for you or a seasonal special passed down from a regular, it’s a reminder that food is meant to be fun.

So next time you stop by, lean in and ask, “Anything off the menu I should know about?”
You might just discover your new favorite thing.

FAQs